Amazing 1-Bowl Creamsicle Cake Joy

Oh, stop right there! If you’re dreaming about those perfect sunny afternoons when you’d beg for that classic orange and vanilla ice pop, then you’ve come to the absolute right place. I am so excited to share this recipe with you because this isn’t just any cake; it’s my Ultimate Moist Orange Creamsicle Layer Cake. Seriously, I’ve worked hard to bring that nostalgic taste of childhood into a simple, beautiful homemade cake.

When I was testing this recipe, one of my goals was making sure everyone—even busy moms like me—could easily create that bright, citrusy flavor without turning it into a huge project. Forget fussy steps! This Creamsicle Cake is reliable, unbelievably moist thanks to my tricks, and has that fluffy frosting everyone raves about. It’s pure sunshine on a plate!

If you want to know more about my journey from corporate life to sharing these home-tested recipes, check out my About Page!

Why This Ultimate Moist Orange Creamsicle Cake is a Family Favorite

Listen, when I present a cake for a family gathering, it needs to pass a serious taste test. This Nostalgic Orange Vanilla Cake doesn’t just pass; it wins every single time! People always ask me how I get the layers so wonderfully soft. It’s because I test these recipes relentlessly until they are foolproof for real life. It’s the perfect Summer Citrus Dessert!

If you’re looking for more reliable baking projects, you should poke around my Desserts category—everything on there has been approved by my picky nephew, too!

Bright Orange Flavor Meets Creamy Vanilla

This is the magic handshake of this cake, folks. We aren’t dealing with artificial, harsh orange flavor here. We use fresh zest to get that bright, slightly tangy citrus punch. Then, we pair it with the cool, sweet vanilla goodness in the frosting. It’s the perfect contrast! That blend is what makes it taste exactly like licking that frozen treat shell—just in glorious cake form.

Achieving a Super Moist Orange Layer Cake

The number one complaint about citrus cakes is dryness, which is unacceptable in my kitchen! That’s why this is my favorite Moist Orange Layer Cake recipe. It relies on a couple of my non-negotiables: buttermilk in the batter gives it a lovely tender crumb, but the real secret weapon is brushing on that orange soaking syrup while the layers are still warm. Trust me, that syrup locks in moisture for days!

Gathering Your Ingredients for the Creamsicle Cake

Okay, now that we know how amazing this cake is going to taste, let’s get our setup ready! Baking is always easier when everything is measured out before you even turn the oven on, you know? We’ve got three main components for this Creamsicle Cake: the beautiful buttermilk sponge layers, the sticky orange soak, and that dreamy vanilla frosting. I’ve listed everything exactly how I use it in my kitchen, so don’t skip anything!

Make sure you grab your eggs before you start mixing—room temperature always blends better! I also highly recommend grating your zest first; that bright smell alone is half the fun of baking this dessert.

For the Buttermilk Sponge Orange Cake Layers

• 1 3/4 cups all-purpose flour
• 1 1/2 cups granulated sugar
• 1 tablespoon baking powder
• 1/2 teaspoon salt
• 1/2 cup unsalted butter, softened
• 3 large eggs
• 1 cup buttermilk
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
• 1/2 cup fresh orange juice
• Zest of 2 large oranges
• 1/4 cup vegetable oil
• 1/2 cup whole milk
• 1/4 cup orange gelatin powder (like JELL-O)

For the Orange Soaking Syrup

This is what guarantees that super moist texture we talked about! Make sure you have exactly what you need here.

• 1 cup powdered sugar
• 1/2 cup hot water (This is just to help dissolve the gelatin and sugar quickly!)
• 1/4 cup orange gelatin powder (Yes, you use the rest of the box here!)

For the Fluffy Creamsicle Frosting

This frosting is truly fluffy, not heavy, because of the cream! Take your time when whipping this up until it feels light as a cloud.

• 1 cup unsalted butter, softened
• 4 cups powdered sugar, sifted
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
• 1/4 cup fresh orange juice
• 1/4 cup heavy cream

Step-by-Step Instructions for the Homemade Creamsicle Cake

Alright, let’s get this show on the road! Making this Homemade Creamsicle Cake is super satisfying, and if you follow these steps exactly, you won’t have any trouble at all. Remember what I always say: baking is chemistry, but having fun makes the results taste better!

Preparing and Baking the Orange Cake Layers

First things first—get that oven heating up to 350°F (175°C) right away, and make sure you’ve generously greased and floured your two 8-inch round pans. Nobody likes a cake that sticks!

In your first big bowl, whisk together all the dry stuff: the flour, sugar, baking powder, and salt. Now, toss in that softened butter and start mixing on low speed until it looks like coarse sand. In your *other* bowl, mix up the wet ingredients: eggs, buttermilk, vanilla, that fresh OJ, zest, and oil. Once that’s happy, slowly add the wet mixture to the dry, mixing just until it barely comes together. Stop mixing when you see flour streaks! Then, gently stir in the whole milk until it’s smooth. Remember that rule: Do not overmix, or we get tough cake!

Divide that gorgeous batter evenly into your pans and bake them for about 28 to 32 minutes. Test them with a toothpick—if it comes out clean, they are ready for the next step!

Infusing Moisture with the Orange Soaking Syrup

This is the fun part that makes this cake so memorable! While the cakes are cooling just slightly (still warm, not piping hot!), prepare that syrup. Dissolve that last bit of orange gelatin powder in the hot water, then whisk in the cup of powdered sugar until everything dissolves smoothly. It smells amazing!

Grab a skewer or a fork and poke holes all over the tops of both cake layers—aim for one every little spot. Gently brush that warm orange syrup evenly over the entire top surface of each layer. Let them cool completely on wire racks after they soak up all that sugary goodness. Seriously, don’t rush this cooling time!

Whipping Up the Fluffy Creamsicle Frosting

Now for the topping! We’re aiming for that light, pillowy texture that screams “creamsicle.” Start by beating that softened butter alone until it’s really creamy—think pale and airy. Then, slowly add in your sifted powdered sugar, bit by bit, beating well after each addition. Once that’s incorporated, mix in the vanilla and the fresh orange juice. The secret to real fluff? Slowly stream in that heavy cream until the whole thing turns into the perfect, spreadable Fluffy Creamsicle Frosting. It should spread like silk!

Assembling Your Perfect Creamsicle Cake

This is where the vision comes together! Place one cooled, soaked layer on your serving plate. Slather on a very generous helping of that fluffy frosting—don’t be shy here! Top it with the second layer. Now, take the rest of your frosting and cover the top and sides completely. If you want really clean edges, pop the whole Creamsicle Cake into the fridge for about 30 minutes before you slice it. It firms up the frosting just enough!

If you’re having fun baking, feel free to check out some more tips over on my general blog page!

Tips for Success with Your Orange Creamsicle Cake

I want your Creamsicle Cake to be perfect, not just good! That’s why I always share the little things that make the difference between a good cake and a *wow* cake. Baked goods always have a few tricky spots, and getting these details right is how you become a more confident baker. You have to learn from the mistakes, right?

I remember the very first time I tried to make this cake for a neighborhood potluck. I thought, “Canned orange juice is cheaper, I’ll just swap it!” Big mistake! The cake tasted flat, and the whole thing was way too sweet. Since then, I learned that for this specific flavor profile, you absolutely cannot skimp on the fresh ingredients. It truly makes or breaks the citrus punch!

Ingredient Notes and Substitutions

Let’s talk ingredients for a second, because sometimes you open the fridge and realize you’re missing that one special item. No panic required!

• Buttermilk SOS: If you don’t have buttermilk, don’t run to the store! Just take one cup of regular whole milk, stir in exactly one tablespoon of white vinegar or lemon juice, and let it sit on the counter for about five minutes. It curdles slightly and becomes a perfect substitute for that tangy lift in our cake.
• Juice Quality Counts: As I learned the hard way, please use freshly squeezed orange juice for both the cake batter and the frosting. The bottled stuff has preservatives that mute that bright citrus pop we are chasing. For the best possible Creamsicle Cake, fresh zest and fresh juice are the way to go.
• Butter Consistency: For the frosting specifically, make sure your butter is truly softened—finger-indented soft—but not melty or greasy. If it’s too warm, your frosting will be runny, and trust me, trying to fix runny frosting always feels like a three-step disaster!

If you struggle with other home-baking tasks, you might enjoy some of the tips in my post about Moist Cinnamon Swirl Apple Bread—it covers how to keep dairy products at the perfect temperature!

Serving Suggestions for This Bright Orange Flavor Dessert

When you have a cake this vibrant, you want to serve it up right! This Bright Orange Flavor Dessert is perfect on its own, but what is a party without a little extra flair?

Because the cake itself is so moist and flavorful, you don’t need heavy sides. I love serving thin slices of this cake right alongside fresh berries in the summer—maybe some raspberries or blueberries to contrast that orange hue. It keeps things light!

For a truly sophisticated touch that leans into that vanilla cream vibe, try serving it with just a small dollop of slightly sweetened whipped cream on the side. Or, if you’re feeling really decadent, a tiny dish of vanilla bean ice cream melting next to a warm slice can’t be beaten. For pairing drinks, skip the heavy sodas. A simple sparkling water with a slice of lime or even some crisp iced tea is the perfect palate cleanser. Everything tastes better when it’s served with a smile, like you can see on my White Pizza post!

Storage and Reheating Instructions for Your Creamsicle Cake

I know you’ll want to save some of this Creamsicle Cake because it tastes even better the next day, but how you store it makes a huge difference! Since we used that beautiful, fluffy buttercream frosting, we have to be mindful of keeping it cool but not letting it get dried out.

For short-term storage, keeping this cake on the counter is usually fine for a day or so, covered properly. But if it’s a hot day or you baked it early, pop it straight into the fridge. The cake layers are so moist from the syrup that they handle the fridge well, which is a big win!

How to Refrigerate Your Cake

The trick here is to avoid drying out the frosting or letting the cake absorb any fridge smells. I always cover my plate or cake stand tightly with plastic wrap. Don’t press the wrap directly onto the frosting—try to drape it loosely over the top so it touches the sides of the cake board, or use tall cake keepers if you have them. This keeps the moisture in the cake layers while protecting that pretty vanilla finish.

It should keep beautifully in the refrigerator for up to four days. You just need to pull it out before serving!

Bringing Your Cake Back to Perfect Temperature

This is crucial for enjoying the best texture! Never serve this cake straight from the cold fridge—it makes the frosting stiff, and the cake crumb will seem dense.

About an hour before you want to slice into that gorgeous Creamsicle Cake, take it out of the refrigerator and let it sit on the counter, still covered. This time gives the butter in the Frosting a chance to soften up back to that perfect creamy texture we worked so hard to achieve. The cake layers will naturally warm up and release all that wonderful orange and vanilla aroma. If you’re in a rush, maybe 45 minutes will do, but an hour is my sweet spot!

Freezing Any Leftovers

If you truly have way too much and need to save it for a future party, yes, you can freeze it! Wrap the slices (or the whole frosted cake, if you must!) very tightly in a double layer of plastic wrap, and then tuck that into aluminum foil. This locks out freezer burn. It keeps well frozen for about two months. When you want to eat it, thaw it slowly in the fridge overnight before setting it out on the counter to come to room temperature.

Frequently Asked Questions About Orange Creamsicle Cake Recipe

I totally get it! When you put this much love into baking a cake, you want to make sure you get every detail right. Plus, sometimes you need little tweaks for your situation. Here are some of the questions I get asked most often about making this amazing Orange Creamsicle Cake Recipe!

Can I turn this Creamsicle Cake into an Easy Poke Cake Recipe?

Oh, absolutely you can! In fact, this recipe is practically begging to be a poke cake, which is perfect for an Easy Creamsicle Dessert setup. If you’re using a 9×13 pan instead of two round layers, just make sure you really poke holes all over the entire surface while it’s still warm. The syrup you make will soak down beautifully. You might even want to reserve just a little bit of the syrup to drizzle over the top *after* you frost it for an extra punch of that bright citrus!

What is the best way to get a strong orange flavor?

This is my hill, and I will die on it! If you want that vibrant, true citrus note—that wonderful Bright Orange Flavor Dessert experience—you HAVE to use fresh orange juice and fresh zest. Bottled juice just doesn’t have the bright aromatic oils that the zest contains. Zest holds the most intense part of the flavor. My tip is to zest the oranges *before* you juice them—it’s easier when the fruit is firmer! If you want even more flavor, you can always add a tiny drop of good quality orange extract to the frosting, but usually, the fresh stuff is more than enough.

If you love easy one-pan desserts, you should definitely check out my instructions for my Easy Poke Cake Recipe; it uses a similar concept but with chocolate!

Can I use a different type of liquid instead of buttermilk?

Yes, that’s another great question! I insist on buttermilk for the slight tang and tenderizing effect it has on the structure, but if you’re in a pinch, you can easily make a substitute. Just measure out one cup of standard whole milk and stir in one tablespoon of white vinegar or lemon juice. Let that sit on your counter for about five to ten minutes until it looks a little ‘curdled.’ That’s your homemade buttermilk, ready to go into the batter for your next batch of Nostalgic Orange Vanilla Cake!

Estimated Nutritional Information for This Orange Dreamsicle Dessert

Okay, let’s talk numbers for a minute! I always include this section because, while we are making treats to enjoy, it’s just responsible cooking to know what’s in what we serve, right? Please remember these figures are just estimates based on the ingredients listed above. Life is too short to stress over exact ounces of sugar when you’re busy enjoying a slice of cake!

This glorious Orange Dreamsicle Dessert certainly falls into the ‘treat’ category, so keep that in mind when planning your menu. But honestly, one slice is totally worth it!

Here is the breakdown per slice:

• Calories: 450
• Sugar: 55g
• Fat: 22g (with 14g being Saturated Fat)
• Carbohydrates: 60g
• Protein: 4g

I also noted the sodium is around 250mg, which is pretty standard for a cake with baking powder and salt in it. Enjoy this incredible Creamsicle Cake responsibly, my friends!

Share Your Homemade Creamsicle Cake Creations

That’s it—you’ve made it through the process and the Ultimate Moist Orange Creamsicle Layer Cake is officially finished! I truly hope this cake brings some sunshine and happy memories to your table, just like it does mine.

Now, this is the part I love the most: seeing your beautiful bakes! There is nothing better than knowing someone else made one of my tried-and-true recipes and loved the results. When you finish decorating your layers and step back to admire your work, take a picture!

Don’t forget to come back here and leave a rating and a quick review. Letting me know how your Creamsicle Cake turned out helps me keep bringing you reliable recipes in the future. Plus, those reviews help other home cooks feel confident trying it out!

Tag Me on Social Media!

I absolutely live for those snapshots! If you post a photo of your finished layer cake, please tag me on social media. I check every tag because I want to see how you styled it. Did you use fresh orange slices on top? Did you make a tall stack? Show it off!

And hey, if you tried any of the serving suggestions I mentioned earlier—like pairing it with fresh berries—snap a picture of that too! Let’s build a community of happy bakers together.

Don’t Forget to Share Your Feedback

If you found this recipe easy, or if you tweaked the frosting ratio just right, please leave a comment below. Seriously, positive feedback makes my whole week! Hearing that you could get this delicious, vibrant cake on the table easily is the biggest compliment I can receive. It proves that we can bring those soulful, comforting flavors back to our everyday lives without the stress.

If you ever run into trouble or have a pressing question while baking, don’t hesitate to send me a message through my Contact Page. Happy baking!

Print